Glad to know I'm not alone haha. I already took the parchment overlay and cranked down both the "lightness" and "saturation" to get the dark outside effect, but I hadn't thought about doing it with another full copy of the image. That should look really good, I'll test it out and post up the result.

I really appreciate the suggestions because I was looking to give the image a "gloomy" appearance but didn't really know how I was going to do it (originally I was just going to do a shadow layer over the outside because I finally figured out how to do that ). Thank you!