Ok, so I made a map. It's prob not a very good map, but it is a map. At this point I prob could just use it as is, except for all the things that kinda suck about it. I'm posting the JPEG image export of the map here to get some feedback on how I can improve the map.
I was actually looking for a place on this forum to post nearly-finished-but-not-quite maps, and I didn't see anywhere that looked appropriate. Is there any place to post mostly-finished maps in need of touch ups, where I can get community advice on improving those maps? I should note that I did see the "Finished Maps" forum, but that seems to me to be a place to post completely finished maps that need no significant revisions. Is that impression accurate?
Anyway, the biggest question I have about this map is, is it legible? Can you tell what the map is showing and can you tell what each individual map element is? Additionally, in terms of style, I was going for a simple, hand-drawn look - mostly because I wasn't sure I could make anything more complicated and also because I essentially was drawing it by hand. Does this map capture that hand-drawn feel at all or does it just look noob-ish?
Beyond those question, the issues I see in this map are:
- First of all, the area I actually need to map out is all in the very southern part of England, and right now I'm showing the coastline for the southern half of England, so the important parts of my map are actually smushed into a pretty small area, which can make some elements, especially smaller text, hard to see/read. And if it's hard for me to see, it's prob really hard for other people to see. The problem is that I want to show enough of the coastline so that the map is immediately recognizable as England, but maybe that's not worth making all the roads and rivers too hard to see. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to deal with this? Should I prioritize enlarging the map elements over making the geographic location of those map elements immediately clear?
- Second, as you can see at the top of the map, I have a box with road names in it. I didn't want to put those road names by the actual roads because of the issues with space I talked about above. In the JPEG image, the box is too small for some reason, but I drew it the right size in CC3+. So why did the box suddenly get smaller? How do I keep it the right size when I export the map? Also, is putting the road names in a box in empty space the best fix for my space issue? Is there a better way to handle this?
- Third, as you can see CC3+ exported my map with some extraneous stuff around it that I don't want. This is not a huge deal because I can just crop the image in my photo editor, but it is kinda annoying. Most annoying of all is the border around the map extending above and below where the parchment background actually ends. Originally, the parchment background filled that entire border, covering up those white strips at the top and bottom of the border/box. Then I brought the top of the border down and the bottom of the border up with the "Numeric Edit" tool, b/c reasons, but immediately after I did that the border snapped back to where it was originally and left the parchment background at the heights I had put the border top/bottom. That might be confusing, but the gist of it is I want the border to hug the parchment background; how do I do that? This again is not a huge deal b/c I can just crop the image to cut out that white space.
Also, is there a way to increase the resolution of the image exports to make the lines crisper and the smaller text easier to read?
Britain Drawn Map Draft 3.JPG